Nutrition

The AIP Diet for Beginners: How It Works, What the Trials Show, and the Risks

The autoimmune protocol diet removes many foods and then reintroduces them. Small uncontrolled studies report better symptoms, but not changed disease. The Mediterranean-style diet has stronger backing.

Acupuncture needle being placed

The autoimmune protocol (AIP) diet is a strict elimination diet: you remove a long list of foods for several weeks, then add them back one at a time to see which ones, if any, make your symptoms worse. It has been tested in a handful of very small studies without control groups. People in those studies reported feeling better, but the diet has not been shown to change the course of any autoimmune disease, and it is not a substitute for medical treatment. The diet with the most support from rheumatology guidelines is a much less restrictive one, the Mediterranean-style diet.

How the AIP diet works

AIP grew out of the paleo diet. It runs in three stages.

  • Elimination. For several weeks (six in the bowel disease study described below) you stop eating grains, legumes, dairy, eggs, nuts and seeds, nightshade vegetables (tomatoes, peppers, eggplant, white potatoes), coffee, alcohol, refined sugar, and processed foods with additives. What is left is meat, fish, most vegetables, some fruit, and fats such as olive oil and avocado.
  • Maintenance. You hold that pattern for several more weeks while tracking symptoms.
  • Reintroduction. Foods return one at a time, a few days apart, so you can spot a reaction. Anything that causes no trouble goes back into your regular diet.

The third stage is the point of the exercise. AIP is meant to be a test, not a permanent way of eating, and people who stay in the elimination stage indefinitely are doing something the protocol never intended.

The theory behind it, and what medicine accepts

AIP rests on the idea of "leaky gut": that certain foods loosen the lining of the intestine, let food particles and bacterial fragments into the bloodstream, and so provoke the immune system. "Leaky gut syndrome" is a popular term, not a medical diagnosis. The underlying measurement, intestinal permeability, is real and can be studied in a laboratory. It rises in inflammatory bowel diseases and with things as ordinary as endurance exercise and anti-inflammatory painkillers.

What has not been shown is that a leaky gut causes autoimmune disease or that tightening it treats one. A review written for clinicians in the journal Gut concluded that it is still unproven that restoring barrier function improves symptoms in digestive or body-wide disease, and that public claims about healing a leaky gut need confirmation before doctors endorse food exclusions or supplements on that basis. So the theory is plausible in outline and unproven in practice.

What the small trials found

Two studies are cited most often. Both are pilots.

Inflammatory bowel disease

In a 2017 study, 15 adults with active Crohn's disease or ulcerative colitis followed six weeks of elimination and five weeks of maintenance. Symptom scores fell: the average partial Mayo score for ulcerative colitis went from 5.8 to 1.0 by week 11, and the Harvey-Bradshaw index for Crohn's disease went from 7 to 3.4. Seven people had a follow-up endoscopy, and six of them showed some improvement.

Now the limits. There was no comparison group. Seven of the 15 were taking biologic drugs throughout. C-reactive protein, a blood marker of inflammation, did not change significantly, and the drop in fecal calprotectin did not reach statistical significance. The researchers also found and treated vitamin D deficiency in three people and iron deficiency in six, which may have helped in its own right. The authors' conclusion was that randomized controlled trials are warranted.

Hashimoto's thyroiditis

A 2019 pilot enrolled 17 women with Hashimoto's in a 10-week online AIP program with health coaching, and 16 finished. Quality-of-life scores improved on all eight scales of a standard questionnaire, and a symptom score dropped from an average of 92 to 29. A sensitive marker of inflammation, hs-CRP, fell from 1.63 to 1.15 mg/L.

Thyroid function did not change. TSH, thyroid hormone levels and both thyroid antibodies were statistically the same at the end as at the start. The women also lost about six pounds on average. Again there was no control group, so nobody can say how much of the benefit came from the diet itself and how much from coaching, group support, weight loss or simply expecting to feel better.

Taken together: about 30 people, no controls, short follow-up. That is enough to justify better studies. It is not enough to tell anyone that AIP treats autoimmune disease.

Risks of the AIP diet

A diet that removes grains, legumes, dairy, eggs, nuts and seeds at once takes out major sources of fiber, calcium, B vitamins and plant protein. The National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health notes, in the context of rheumatoid arthritis, that restrictive diets which eliminate major food groups may risk nutritional deficiencies, and that some people on special diets lost weight without meaning to, which is a problem for anyone already at or below a healthy weight.

Other things to think about before starting:

  • Cost and effort. Nearly every meal has to be cooked from scratch. Eating out or with family gets hard.
  • Disordered eating. Long lists of forbidden foods can feed anxiety around food. Anyone with a history of an eating disorder should avoid elimination diets unless a clinician is supervising.
  • Pregnancy, breastfeeding, childhood and older age. Nutrient needs are higher or margins are thinner. AIP has not been studied in these groups.
  • False confidence. Feeling better is not the same as the disease being quiet. In the Hashimoto's study, symptoms improved while thyroid tests stayed the same. Keep your blood tests and specialist visits on schedule and do not change or stop prescribed medicine because of how you feel on a diet.

If you want to try AIP, do it for a defined period with your doctor's knowledge and, ideally, a registered dietitian's help, and plan the reintroduction stage before you begin.

The Mediterranean diet: less strict, better studied

A Mediterranean-style diet is built on vegetables, fruit, whole grains, beans, nuts, olive oil and fish, with little red meat and few sweets. Notice that it includes several foods AIP removes.

In its 2022 guideline on integrative care for rheumatoid arthritis, the American College of Rheumatology conditionally recommended a Mediterranean-style diet over no formally defined diet. It did not recommend any other formally defined diet, and it framed diet as an addition to disease-modifying drugs. "Conditional" means the evidence is limited and the choice depends on the patient.

The research behind that is modest but real. A 2018 systematic review found four prospective studies in rheumatoid arthritis. Two intervention studies reported less pain and better physical function in the Mediterranean diet groups, and one reported lower disease activity scores. The reviewers judged the evidence insufficient to recommend the diet for preventing the disease. A 2025 analysis of 117,341 UK Biobank participants followed for about nine years found that people who followed the diet most closely were less likely to develop rheumatoid arthritis than those who followed it least (hazard ratio 0.71). That is an observational finding, so it shows an association and cannot prove the diet was the cause.

Other diets you may hear about

  • Gluten-free. This is the proven treatment for celiac disease and the related skin condition dermatitis herpetiformis; the NIDDK calls it the only treatment for the underlying disease. For other autoimmune conditions the evidence is thin. Get tested for celiac disease before you cut gluten, since the tests depend on your eating it.
  • Fish oil. NCCIH cites a 2017 review of 22 studies that found a favorable effect of omega-3 supplements on pain in rheumatoid arthritis. For multiple sclerosis, the American Academy of Neurology rated fish oil as probably ineffective for relapses, disability and fatigue. The answer differs by disease. Check with your doctor or pharmacist before taking it, particularly if you use blood thinners.
  • Vegan, fasting and "anti-inflammatory" diets. NCCIH describes the effects of special diets on rheumatoid arthritis as uncertain because very little research exists.

Where acupuncture, Ayurveda and herbs fit

Ayurveda has its own long tradition of dietary advice based on digestion and body constitution. That advice rests on tradition; it has not been put through clinical trials for autoimmune disease, and we will not claim otherwise. In practice much of it (regular meals, cooked vegetables, fewer processed foods) overlaps with ordinary good nutrition and can sit comfortably beside a Mediterranean-style pattern.

Acupuncture is not a dietary treatment. Some people use it for symptoms that often accompany autoimmune illness, such as pain, poor sleep or irritable bowel symptoms. It does not replace immune-modifying medicine.

Be careful with herbs and supplements sold alongside diet programs. Turmeric is a common example: NCCIH reports liver damage in some people using highly absorbable curcumin products and says turmeric supplements may be unsafe in pregnancy. Herbs can also interact with immune-suppressing drugs. Check with your doctor or pharmacist before taking any of them.

When to see a doctor

See your doctor before starting a restrictive diet if you are pregnant, underweight, diabetic, or have kidney disease or a history of disordered eating. While on any elimination diet, call your doctor if you have:

  • Weight loss you did not intend, dizziness or unusual weakness
  • Blood in the stool, persistent diarrhea or severe belly pain
  • New joint swelling, rash, fever or other signs of a flare
  • Numbness, vision changes or chest pain, which need urgent care
  • Growing fear or guilt around eating

Frequently asked questions

How long should the elimination stage last?

The published studies used six weeks of elimination followed by a maintenance period, about 10 to 11 weeks in total. There is no evidence that staying in elimination for longer adds benefit, and the nutritional risk grows with time.

Can AIP put autoimmune disease into remission?

No study has shown that. In the bowel disease pilot, symptom scores improved while most participants continued their usual medicines, and there was no control group. In the Hashimoto's pilot, thyroid tests and antibodies did not change.

Is AIP better than the Mediterranean diet?

The two have never been compared head to head. The Mediterranean-style diet has more research behind it, is recommended conditionally by the American College of Rheumatology for rheumatoid arthritis, and is far easier to keep up.

Do I have to give up nightshades?

The idea that tomatoes, peppers and potatoes worsen autoimmune disease has not been tested in good trials. If you suspect one of them, the reintroduction approach, removing it for a few weeks and then bringing it back, is a reasonable way to find out.

Can I do AIP while taking my medication?

Yes, and you should keep taking it. Tell your prescriber, because large changes in diet and weight can affect how some drugs are dosed and monitored.

Netra Integrative Health Clinic offers Ayurvedic care and acupuncture as complementary care alongside your own physician. The clinic is at 5001 Hadley Road, Suite 210, South Plainfield, NJ 07080, open by appointment Monday to Saturday, 9:00 AM to 6:00 PM. Call (908) 402-7301 or schedule an appointment. Ayurvedic consultations are self-pay; only acupuncture is billed to insurance.

This article is general information and does not replace assessment or advice from your own doctor or dietitian. Do not change prescribed treatment because of anything you read here.