Sleep and energy

ME/CFS and Chronic Fatigue: Pacing, Current Guidance and Complementary Care

What ME/CFS is, why pacing has replaced graded exercise, and what the research on acupuncture and herbs does and does not show.

Acupuncture needle being placed

Planning a visit? See ME/CFS care in South Plainfield for what care at our clinic involves.

ME/CFS (myalgic encephalomyelitis/chronic fatigue syndrome) is a long-lasting biological illness in which severe fatigue is not relieved by rest and symptoms get worse after physical or mental effort. There is no cure and no approved drug. Current guidance centers on pacing, which means keeping activity inside your energy limit, and on treating the most troublesome symptoms one at a time. Acupuncture and herbs have been studied, but the trials are small and weak, so they can be tried as comfort measures at most and never as a replacement for medical care.

What ME/CFS is

The CDC describes ME/CFS as a serious illness affecting many parts of the body that keeps people from their usual activities. It estimates that up to 3.3 million people in the United States have it and that more than 9 in 10 of them have never been diagnosed. It is most common in middle age, affects women more often than men, and also occurs in teenagers and children. About 1 in 4 people with ME/CFS are confined to bed at some point in the illness.

No single cause is known. Many people date the start to an infection. The CDC's Long COVID page lists fatigue that interferes with daily life, trouble thinking, and symptoms that worsen after effort among common complaints after COVID-19, and a review in American Family Physician notes that post-COVID illness may increase the number of people with ME/CFS.

Chronic fatigue is not the same as ME/CFS

The two phrases get mixed up. "Chronic fatigue" just means tiredness lasting six months or more, and it has many causes: anemia, thyroid disease, sleep apnea, depression, medicines and others. The American Family Physician review is clear that most people with long-running fatigue do not have ME/CFS.

ME/CFS is a specific diagnosis. Under the 2015 National Academy of Medicine criteria described in that review, a person must have all three of these for at least six months:

  • A profound, new drop in the ability to do what they could do before, with fatigue
  • Post-exertional malaise
  • Unrefreshing sleep

plus at least one of: problems with thinking and memory, or symptoms that worsen on standing upright (orthostatic intolerance). No blood test or scan confirms it. The diagnosis is made from the history after other conditions have been ruled out.

Post-exertional malaise: the defining feature

Post-exertional malaise, or PEM, is a worsening of symptoms after activity that would not have been a problem before the illness. A shower, a phone call or a short walk can be enough. The NICE guideline on ME/CFS notes that the worsening is often delayed by 12 to 48 hours and can last days or weeks. People describe it as a crash.

That delay is what makes ME/CFS so hard to manage by instinct. You feel fairly well on Tuesday, do a little more, and pay for it on Thursday. It is also why advice that works for ordinary tiredness, such as pushing through or building up exercise week by week, can backfire.

Current guidance: pacing has replaced graded exercise

For years many patients were prescribed graded exercise therapy, a program of fixed, stepwise increases in activity. That has changed. The American Family Physician review states that graded exercise therapy is no longer recommended for ME/CFS and is likely harmful compared with standard care, after the main trial behind it was reanalyzed and found to be flawed. The CDC's clinical guidance says that standard exercise recommendations for healthy people can substantially harm patients with ME/CFS and that exercise is not a cure.

The same review lists cognitive behavioral therapy as ineffective for the fatigue itself, although it may help some people cope, as it can with any long illness.

How pacing works

NICE defines your energy limit as the amount of energy you have for all activities without triggering an increase in symptoms. Energy management, or pacing, is the self-management strategy of staying within that limit. The CDC calls the same idea staying inside your "energy envelope." In practice:

  1. Find your baseline. Keep a simple diary of activity and symptoms for two weeks. Count mental and emotional effort, not just physical.
  2. Stop before you are tired. The review suggests the phrase "Stop, rest, pace."
  3. Break tasks up. Ten minutes of cooking, then sitting down, is easier on the body than thirty minutes straight.
  4. Plan rest ahead of demands. Rest before and after a medical appointment or family event.
  5. Do not spend a good day all at once. Overdoing it on good days is the most common route to a crash.

Pacing is not complete rest. The CDC also warns that deconditioning is harmful, so activity you tolerate should be kept up. The aim is fewer crashes, not zero movement.

What conventional care involves

A doctor's first job is to check for other explanations: blood count, iron, thyroid, blood sugar, sleep disorders, mood, medicines. After diagnosis, the CDC advises that patient, family and clinician decide together which symptom causes the most trouble and treat that first.

  • Sleep. Good sleep habits first. If medicine is needed, CDC guidance is the smallest dose for the shortest possible time, and a sleep study may be suggested.
  • Pain. Over-the-counter pain relievers first, then referral to a pain specialist if needed. Non-drug options the CDC lists include stretching, gentle massage, heat and water therapy.
  • Dizziness on standing, memory and concentration problems, low mood and anxiety. Each is assessed and managed individually.

The American Family Physician review advises starting any medicine at a low dose, because people with ME/CFS are often sensitive to drugs. It is frank that the outlook is uncertain and that no proven cure exists. Some people improve over time. Others stay ill for years.

What the acupuncture research shows

The largest pooled analysis we could read is a 2019 systematic review and meta-analysis in Acupuncture in Medicine. It combined 16 trials with 1,346 participants. In four trials with 281 people, those given acupuncture were about twice as likely to be rated as responders as those given sham acupuncture (relative risk 2.08). Fatigue scores also fell more with acupuncture than with other comparison treatments.

Those numbers look good until you read the rest. The authors wrote that most studies had low methodological quality, rated both main outcomes as low certainty, and concluded that no firm conclusion could be reached because of limited data, poor quality and effect sizes that may be exaggerated. Most of the trials were short and used different definitions of chronic fatigue, and it is unclear how many participants had PEM, which is the core of ME/CFS as it is defined today.

So the fair summary is this: acupuncture might reduce fatigue ratings for some people, and the evidence is too weak to say so with confidence. The CDC's clinical guidance mentions acupuncture in one place only, noting that when done by a licensed practitioner it might help with pain for some patients.

There is a practical point as well. Getting to a clinic costs energy. Travel, waiting and conversation all count against your limit. If you try acupuncture, schedule it on a day with nothing else planned, ask for a short, gentle session, and stop if visits set off crashes.

What the herbal research shows

Less. The CDC's clinical guidance does not list any herb or supplement as a treatment for ME/CFS. Ginseng is the herb most often studied for tiredness. The American Family Physician review says it may help nonspecific fatigue, which is a different thing from ME/CFS. NCCIH describes the overall research on Asian ginseng as limited, with most trials having fewer than 200 participants and lasting under three months, and results for fatigue inconsistent.

Ginseng is a stimulating herb, and insomnia is its most common side effect, which matters in an illness where sleep is already unrefreshing. NCCIH also notes that it may lower blood sugar, may interfere with blood clotting, may worsen autoimmune disorders, and that some experts advise against it in pregnancy and breastfeeding. Short-term use of up to six months appears safe for most people, but long-term safety is uncertain. Because people with ME/CFS are often sensitive to medicines, the same caution applies to herbs. Check with your doctor or pharmacist before starting any herbal product, and tell them everything you take.

Ayurvedic and Chinese herbal formulas have not been tested in good-quality ME/CFS trials that we could verify. Anyone who tells you a formula will cure ME/CFS is claiming more than the research supports.

Yoga, massage and breathing

The CDC lists gentle massage, deep breathing and muscle relaxation as options for pain, stress and anxiety in people who are less severely affected. It cautions that movement therapies such as stretching, yoga and tai chi need careful thought so they do not trigger PEM. Lying-down breathing practice and very short, supported postures are usually the safest starting point, and only within your limit.

What our clinic can and cannot do

Netra Integrative Health Clinic provides acupuncture, Ayurvedic medicine and herbal medicine as complementary care alongside your own physician. The clinic does not diagnose ME/CFS, order labs or prescribe drugs. Visits are in person only, which will not suit people who are housebound or bedbound. For those who can travel, the sensible goals are modest ones such as pain, sleep and stress, reviewed after a few visits. See how many acupuncture sessions people usually need for how a trial of treatment is typically structured.

When to see a doctor

See your doctor if fatigue has lasted more than a few weeks, if you crash after ordinary activity, or if you have not recovered after an infection. Seek urgent care for:

  • Chest pain, shortness of breath at rest, or fainting
  • New weakness on one side, trouble speaking, or sudden confusion
  • Unexplained weight loss, fevers or drenching night sweats
  • Black stools or other signs of bleeding
  • Being unable to eat or drink enough
  • Thoughts of suicide or self-harm. In the US, call or text 988.

New or changed symptoms in someone who already has ME/CFS deserve a fresh look too. Not everything is the ME/CFS.

Frequently asked questions

Is ME/CFS a psychological illness?

No. The CDC describes it as a biological illness. Depression and anxiety can occur alongside it, as with any long illness, and deserve treatment in their own right.

Should I exercise more to get my energy back?

Not by pushing through. Graded exercise therapy is no longer recommended, and the CDC warns that standard exercise advice can harm people with ME/CFS. Stay as active as you can without setting off symptoms, and discuss any plan with your doctor.

Can acupuncture cure chronic fatigue syndrome?

No treatment has been shown to cure it. Pooled trials suggest acupuncture may ease fatigue for some people, but the evidence is rated low certainty.

Are there supplements proven to help?

None is established. If a blood test shows you are low in something such as iron or vitamin B12, your doctor will treat that. Otherwise be wary of costly supplement programs.

How is Long COVID related?

Some people with Long COVID have fatigue, brain fog and post-exertional malaise that look much like ME/CFS. The CDC says most people with Long COVID symptoms improve considerably after three months, while others take much longer.

Does insurance cover acupuncture for ME/CFS?

Coverage depends on your plan and the reason for treatment. At this clinic only acupuncture is billed to insurance, and herbs and Ayurvedic care are self-pay. You can ask for a free benefits check at our insurance verification page.

Netra Integrative Health Clinic is at 5001 Hadley Road, Suite 210, South Plainfield, NJ 07080. Hours are Monday to Saturday, 9:00 AM to 6:00 PM, by appointment only. Call (908) 402-7301 or schedule an appointment.

This article is general information. It does not replace an assessment by your own doctor, and it should not be used to diagnose or treat ME/CFS on your own.