Digestive

Low Stomach Acid (Hypochlorhydria): Symptoms, Causes and Testing

Low stomach acid is real and has known causes, but many popular claims and home tests are unproven. What is established, how doctors test, and how Ayurveda's weak agni compares.

Acupuncture needle being placed

Low stomach acid, called hypochlorhydria, is a genuine medical finding. It occurs with long-term acid-suppressing medicine, with chronic Helicobacter pylori infection, with autoimmune gastritis and, to some degree, with ageing. Its proven consequences are poorer absorption of vitamin B12 and iron and a somewhat higher chance of bacterial overgrowth in the small intestine. What is not established is the popular claim that low acid is the hidden cause of most heartburn, bloating and fatigue, or that a home baking-soda test can detect it.

What stomach acid does

Cells in the stomach lining secrete hydrochloric acid. The acid has several jobs:

  • It activates pepsin, the enzyme that begins protein digestion.
  • It frees vitamin B12 from the proteins in food. The NIH Office of Dietary Supplements describes this as the first step in B12 absorption.
  • It keeps iron in a form the gut can absorb.
  • It kills many of the bacteria swallowed with food and saliva.

Hypochlorhydria means the stomach makes less acid than normal. Achlorhydria means it makes essentially none.

Symptoms attributed to low stomach acid

There is no symptom that reliably points to low acid. Many people with documented hypochlorhydria feel nothing unusual. The National Institute of Diabetes and Digestive and Kidney Diseases (NIDDK) notes that most people with gastritis, the main underlying cause, have no symptoms at all.

When symptoms do occur they tend to be indirect:

  • Indigestion-type complaints: early fullness, feeling overly full after meals, upper abdominal discomfort, nausea
  • Bloating and gas
  • Signs of vitamin B12 deficiency: tiredness, numbness or tingling in the hands and feet, a sore tongue, memory trouble
  • Signs of iron deficiency: fatigue, pallor, shortness of breath on exertion

Each of these is far more often caused by something else. Wellness websites frequently list heartburn, brittle nails, hair loss, acne and food sensitivities as signs of low acid. Those links have not been demonstrated in clinical studies.

Causes that are established

Acid-suppressing medicines

Proton pump inhibitors (PPIs) such as omeprazole and lansoprazole, and H2 blockers, lower stomach acid on purpose. That is how they treat reflux and ulcers and protect the stomach in people on certain drugs. This is a very common reason for low acid.

H. pylori infection and atrophic gastritis

NIDDK estimates that about 35% of people in the United States carry H. pylori, rising to 50% to 60% of adults over 60. In some carriers, decades of inflammation destroy the glands in the stomach lining that produce acid and enzymes. That end stage is atrophic gastritis. The American Gastroenterological Association's 2021 clinical practice update defines it as loss of gastric glands in the setting of chronic inflammation, mainly due to H. pylori or autoimmunity, and classifies it as a precancerous condition that should be confirmed by biopsy.

Autoimmune gastritis

Here the immune system attacks the stomach's own acid-producing cells. NIDDK notes it is more common in people with type 1 diabetes, Addison's disease or autoimmune thyroid disease such as Hashimoto's. It can lead to pernicious anemia, a severe B12 deficiency caused by loss of intrinsic factor, the stomach protein needed to absorb B12.

Age

The Office of Dietary Supplements states that many older adults do not have enough hydrochloric acid in their stomach to absorb the B12 naturally present in food, and advises people over 50 to get most of their B12 from fortified foods or supplements.

Stomach surgery

Operations that remove or bypass part of the stomach, including some weight-loss procedures, reduce the acid-producing area.

What low acid is known to cause

  • Vitamin B12 deficiency. The NIH fact sheet reports that B12 deficiency affects between 3% and 43% of older adults, a wide range that depends on how deficiency is defined. It also notes that acid-reducing drugs can interfere with B12 absorption from food.
  • Iron deficiency. NIDDK lists iron-deficiency anemia as a complication of both H. pylori and autoimmune gastritis.
  • Small intestinal bacterial overgrowth (SIBO). With less acid, more bacteria survive the stomach. A meta-analysis of 19 studies with 7,055 subjects found PPI use associated with a moderately increased risk of SIBO (odds ratio 1.71). SIBO can cause bloating, gas and diarrhea.
  • Altered absorption of some medicines that need an acidic stomach to dissolve.

What is not established

"Most reflux is really low acid." This is a staple of wellness media. The argument is that too little acid causes food to linger and push upward. There is no good clinical evidence for it. Reflux symptoms come from stomach contents, acid included, reaching the esophagus, and acid-lowering medicine relieves them in most patients.

The baking soda burp test. You drink baking soda in water and time how long it takes to belch. This is not a validated medical test. Burping depends on swallowed air, how fast the stomach empties and many other things, and the result should not guide any decision.

The "betaine HCl challenge." Taking acid capsules and increasing the number until you feel burning is promoted as a do-it-yourself diagnostic. It has not been validated, and it risks irritating the stomach lining.

Betaine HCl as a treatment. Research here is very limited. In a pilot study in six healthy volunteers whose acid had been suppressed with a PPI, a single dose of betaine HCl lowered stomach pH within minutes, and the effect wore off after a little more than an hour. That shows the capsules can acidify the stomach briefly. It does not show that they relieve symptoms or correct nutrient deficiencies, and the study was not designed to test that. People with ulcers or gastritis, and those taking anti-inflammatory painkillers or steroids, are generally cautioned against acid supplements. Check with your doctor or pharmacist before using one.

Apple cider vinegar and digestive bitters. These are traditional appetite and digestion aids. They are not known to correct hypochlorhydria.

How doctors actually test

Direct measurement of stomach acid is seldom needed. Instead, doctors look for the causes and the consequences.

  • Medication review. Often the answer is on the medicine list.
  • Blood tests for anemia, vitamin B12 and iron stores. In suspected autoimmune gastritis, antibody tests and other blood markers of stomach function may be added.
  • H. pylori testing by urea breath test or stool test, as described by NIDDK.
  • Upper endoscopy with biopsies. This is how atrophic gastritis is confirmed, and it is the test that matters most because of the cancer risk.
  • Gastric pH measurement through a tube, a wireless capsule or during endoscopy exists, but is mostly used in research and specialist centres.

What conventional care involves

Treatment targets the cause.

  • H. pylori is treated with a combination of antibiotics and an acid reducer, followed by a repeat test at least four weeks after treatment to confirm it has cleared, per NIDDK.
  • Deficiencies are corrected with B12, iron or both. Pernicious anemia is usually treated with B12 injections.
  • Atrophic gastritis may call for periodic endoscopic surveillance, decided by a gastroenterologist.
  • PPI use is reviewed. The AGA's 2022 advice on de-prescribing PPIs says everyone taking a PPI should have the reason for it reviewed regularly, and that people without a definite ongoing indication should be considered for a trial of stopping. It also says some patients, including those with complicated reflux disease, should stay on treatment. This is a conversation to have with your prescriber. Do not stop a PPI on your own; some people are on it to prevent bleeding or protect the esophagus.

The Ayurvedic parallel: weak agni

Ayurveda has no concept of hydrochloric acid, but it places digestive capacity, called agni or digestive fire, at the centre of health. A weak, sluggish fire is termed mandagni. Its classical description will sound familiar: heaviness after eating, poor appetite, bloating, a coated tongue, and fatigue. Incompletely digested food is said to form ama, a concept with no direct biomedical equivalent.

Traditional measures for mandagni include eating the main meal at midday, favouring warm, freshly cooked food, not eating until the previous meal has been digested, sipping warm water, and using spices such as fresh ginger, cumin, black pepper and long pepper, sometimes as the formula trikatu. Chinese medicine describes a comparable pattern as spleen and stomach qi deficiency.

The parallel is conceptual. Agni is not a measurement of gastric pH, and Ayurvedic assessment cannot tell you whether your stomach acid is low. No trial has shown that Ayurvedic herbs raise stomach acid or treat atrophic gastritis, and the National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health (NCCIH) states that few well-designed trials support Ayurvedic approaches generally. Pungent herbs can aggravate gastritis, ulcers and reflux. They can interact with prescription drugs, and concentrated preparations are best avoided in pregnancy unless your obstetric provider agrees. NCCIH also warns of heavy metals in some Ayurvedic products. Check with your doctor or pharmacist first.

For the symptom cluster itself, acupuncture has some trial support. In a randomized trial of 278 adults with postprandial distress syndrome, a form of functional dyspepsia marked by fullness after meals and early satiety, 83.0% responded after four weeks of acupuncture versus 51.6% after sham treatment. The trial did not measure stomach acid, relied on self-reported symptoms, and needs replication outside China. It suggests acupuncture may ease meal-related fullness. It says nothing about correcting acid levels.

When to see a doctor

See your doctor for indigestion that lasts more than a few weeks, and promptly if you have:

  • Black, tarry stools, or vomit that is bloody or looks like coffee grounds
  • Unintended weight loss or loss of appetite
  • Difficulty or pain when swallowing
  • Persistent vomiting
  • Numbness or tingling in the hands or feet, unsteadiness, or memory changes
  • Unusual tiredness, breathlessness or pallor
  • Indigestion that is new in later life, or a family history of stomach cancer

Chest pain that spreads to the arm or jaw, or comes with sweating or shortness of breath, needs emergency care. Do not assume it is indigestion.

Frequently asked questions

How do I know if I have low stomach acid?

You cannot tell from symptoms. A doctor identifies it indirectly, through your medicines, blood tests for B12 and iron, H. pylori testing and, when indicated, endoscopy with biopsies.

Does the baking soda test work?

No. It has not been validated, and belching is influenced by too many unrelated factors.

Can low stomach acid cause heartburn or reflux?

This is widely claimed online and not supported by clinical evidence. If you have frequent heartburn, see your doctor for an assessment.

Should I take betaine HCl?

There is no good evidence that it helps symptoms, and it can irritate the stomach. It is unsuitable for people with ulcers or gastritis. Talk to your doctor or pharmacist before trying it.

Is weak agni the same thing as low stomach acid?

No. Agni is a traditional Ayurvedic concept describing overall digestive strength. The symptoms overlap, but one cannot be used to diagnose the other.

Do acid-reducing medicines cause problems in the long run?

They can reduce B12 absorption and are associated with a moderately higher risk of SIBO. For many people the benefits clearly outweigh these risks. Ask your prescriber to review whether you still need yours; do not stop it yourself.

Netra Integrative Health Clinic provides acupuncture, Ayurvedic and Chinese medicine as complementary care alongside your own physician. The clinic does not order labs, prescribe drugs or diagnose medical disease, so testing for low stomach acid and its causes is done through your doctor. We are at 5001 Hadley Road, Suite 210, South Plainfield, NJ 07080, open Monday to Saturday, 9:00 AM to 6:00 PM, by appointment only. Call (908) 402-7301 or schedule an appointment.

This article is general information and does not replace an assessment by your own doctor. Do not stop or change any prescribed medicine, including acid-reducing medicine, without speaking to the clinician who prescribed it.