Nutrition

Does Milk Really Build Strong Bones? Calcium, Vitamin D and Non-Dairy Options

Milk is a convenient source of calcium, protein and vitamin D, but it is not essential for bone health and more of it does not guarantee fewer fractures. Here is what the research shows and how to get calcium without dairy.

Acupuncture needle being placed

Planning a visit? See Osteoporosis care in South Plainfield for what care at our clinic involves.

Milk helps you build and keep bone because it is a convenient source of calcium, protein and, when fortified, vitamin D. It is not required for strong bones, and drinking more of it does not by itself prevent fractures. What bones need is enough calcium and vitamin D from any source, regular weight-bearing exercise, adequate protein, and no smoking. People who avoid dairy can meet those needs with fortified foods, calcium-set tofu, canned fish with bones and certain greens.

How bones use calcium and vitamin D

Bone is living tissue that is broken down and rebuilt throughout life. Calcium is the main mineral in that structure. Vitamin D is what lets you take calcium in: the NIH Office of Dietary Supplements explains that vitamin D increases calcium absorption from the gut and keeps blood calcium and phosphate at levels that allow bone to mineralize normally. Without enough of it, children develop rickets and adults develop osteomalacia, or soft bones.

Bone mass builds through childhood and the teenage years and peaks in early adulthood. After that the goal is to slow the loss. This is why calcium needs are highest in adolescence and rise again later in life.

How much you need

The NIH calcium fact sheet lists these recommended daily amounts:

  • Ages 9 to 18: 1,300 mg
  • Adults 19 to 50: 1,000 mg
  • Women 51 to 70: 1,200 mg; men 51 to 70: 1,000 mg
  • Everyone over 70: 1,200 mg

For vitamin D, the recommended amount is 600 IU a day from age 1 to 70 and 800 IU after 70. One cup of milk supplies roughly 275 to 300 mg of calcium, and almost all U.S. milk is fortified with about 100 IU of vitamin D per cup. Three cups a day would cover most of an adult's calcium need, which is where the old "three glasses" advice comes from.

What the research says about milk and fractures

Here the picture is less tidy than the advertising. About 72 percent of the calcium Americans eat comes from dairy, so milk plainly helps people reach their intake target. Whether drinking more milk leads to fewer broken bones is a separate question, and the answer from long-term studies is mixed.

The best-known challenge came from a 2014 Swedish study in The BMJ that followed 61,433 women for about 20 years and 45,339 men for about 11 years. Higher milk intake was not linked to fewer fractures. In women, each daily glass was tied to a slightly higher rate of hip fracture, and women drinking three or more glasses a day had a higher death rate than those drinking less than one. Fermented milk products such as yogurt showed the opposite pattern. The authors urged caution: this was an observational study, other factors could explain the result, and they said the findings needed to be repeated before being used for dietary advice. It does not show that milk harms bones. It does show that milk alone is no guarantee.

On the other side, the NIH fact sheet describes a two-year trial in which skim milk enriched with calcium and vitamin D increased bone density at the hip. Studies of calcium intake and bone density in general are inconsistent, with some finding a benefit only in certain groups.

What about supplements?

Trials of calcium and vitamin D pills have also produced uneven results. According to the NIH calcium fact sheet, one analysis of eight trials found that calcium plus vitamin D lowered total fractures by 15 percent and hip fractures by 30 percent, while other analyses found no benefit. The NIH vitamin D fact sheet states that combined supplements reduce fractures in older adults living in institutions, that the benefit is inconsistent for people living in the community, and that vitamin D taken alone appears to have no effect on fracture risk.

The U.S. Preventive Services Task Force concluded that daily doses below 1,000 mg of calcium and 400 IU of vitamin D do not prevent fractures in postmenopausal women, and that evidence for higher doses was inadequate. Harvard's Nutrition Source notes that the benefit appears greater in frail older adults than in healthy, independent ones.

More is not better. The upper limit for calcium is 2,500 mg a day for adults up to 50 and 2,000 mg after that. Some studies link high-dose calcium supplements with kidney stones and heart disease, though other studies do not, and calcium from food has not shown the same pattern. Calcium supplements also block absorption of several medicines, including levothyroxine and some antibiotics. Check with your doctor or pharmacist before starting calcium or vitamin D supplements, and about how to space them from your other medicines.

Non-dairy sources of calcium

The amount on the label is only half the story, because absorption differs by food. The NIH fact sheet puts absorption from dairy and fortified foods at about 30 percent. Spinach looks rich in calcium on paper, but its oxalate holds on to the mineral and only about 5 percent is absorbed. Calcium from kale, broccoli and cabbage is absorbed about as well as from milk, though each serving contains less. Harvard gives bok choy as a good example: about 160 mg per cooked cup, with roughly half absorbed.

Useful non-dairy sources, with amounts from the NIH table:

  • Calcium-fortified orange juice, 1 cup: 349 mg
  • Canned sardines with bones, 3 oz: 325 mg
  • Calcium-fortified soy milk, 1 cup: 299 mg
  • Firm tofu made with calcium sulfate, ½ cup: 253 mg
  • Canned pink salmon with bones, 3 oz: 181 mg
  • Cooked kale, 1 cup: 94 mg
  • Raw bok choy, 1 cup: 74 mg

Shake fortified plant milks before pouring, since the added calcium can settle. Check the label too. Not every almond, oat or rice drink is fortified, and most have far less protein than cow's milk or soy milk.

If lactose is the problem, you may not need to give up dairy. The National Institute of Diabetes and Digestive and Kidney Diseases says many people with lactose intolerance can handle about 12 grams of lactose, the amount in one cup of milk, with no or mild symptoms. Lactose-free milk has the same nutrients as regular milk.

Beyond calcium: what else protects bone

The National Institute of Arthritis and Musculoskeletal and Skin Diseases lists the main steps for prevention: weight-bearing exercise such as walking, a diet with enough calcium and vitamin D, not smoking, and keeping alcohol moderate. It also lists poor protein intake and excessive dieting as risk factors. Low body weight, a parent with a hip fracture, early menopause, and long-term use of steroid medicines or certain other drugs all raise risk regardless of how much milk you drink.

Falls matter too, because many fractures happen during a fall. Balance training, good lighting, a vision check and a review of medicines that cause dizziness all reduce that risk.

What conventional care involves

Osteoporosis causes no symptoms until a bone breaks, so it is found by screening. The U.S. Preventive Services Task Force recommends a bone density test for all women aged 65 and older, and for younger postmenopausal women whose risk is raised. It found the evidence insufficient to recommend for or against routine screening in men, so that decision is made individually.

When bone density is low or a fragility fracture has occurred, doctors prescribe medicines that are proven to lower fracture risk, and they check for causes such as vitamin D deficiency, thyroid or parathyroid problems, and celiac disease. Diet and exercise support these medicines. They do not replace them.

What Ayurveda, Chinese medicine and acupuncture can and cannot offer

Ayurveda has long valued milk, usually served warm and often spiced, along with sesame seeds, ghee and leafy greens as foods for bone tissue, which it calls asthi dhatu. Chinese medicine links bone to the Kidney system and uses herbal formulas in older adults. These are traditional frameworks. Clinical trials of Ayurvedic or Chinese herbs for bone density are small and of uneven quality, and none of these products has been shown to prevent fractures the way prescription osteoporosis medicines have. Acupuncture has not been shown to build bone. It is sometimes used for pain, and people with fragile bones should tell their practitioner about their diagnosis.

Herbal products can interact with prescription drugs, including osteoporosis medicines, blood thinners and thyroid medicine, and many are not suitable during pregnancy or breastfeeding. Check with your doctor or pharmacist before taking any. At our clinic, Ayurvedic and Chinese medicine consultations can cover diet and daily habits as a complement to your physician's care. We do not order bone density scans or prescribe osteoporosis medicine.

When to see a doctor

  • A broken bone after a minor fall or bump, at any adult age
  • Loss of height, a stooped upper back, or sudden back pain, which may signal a spinal fracture
  • You are a woman aged 65 or older and have never had a bone density test
  • Menopause before age 45, or periods that stopped for months for other reasons
  • Long-term treatment with steroid tablets, some seizure or cancer medicines, or acid-blocking drugs
  • A condition that affects absorption, such as celiac disease or weight loss surgery, or a history of an eating disorder
  • A child or teenager who avoids all dairy and fortified foods

Frequently asked questions

Do adults need milk for strong bones?

No. Adults need enough calcium, vitamin D and protein, plus weight-bearing exercise. Milk is one easy way to get the first three. Fortified soy milk, yogurt, tofu, canned fish with bones and low-oxalate greens can do the same job.

Does milk cause osteoporosis or weaken bones?

There is no good evidence that it does. One large Swedish study linked high milk intake with slightly more hip fractures in women, but the authors themselves said the result could be due to other factors and should not guide diet advice until confirmed.

Is plant milk as good as cow's milk for bones?

It depends on the product. Fortified soy milk has about the same calcium per cup as cow's milk, according to NIH figures, and similar protein. Many other plant drinks are low in protein, and some are not fortified. Read the label.

Should I take a calcium supplement?

Food first. If your diet falls short, a supplement can close the gap, but high doses carry possible risks and can interfere with medicines. Check with your doctor or pharmacist about whether you need one and how much.

Is spinach a good source of calcium?

Not really. Only about 5 percent of the calcium in spinach is absorbed because of its oxalate content. Kale, bok choy and broccoli are better choices among greens.

How do I know if my bones are thinning?

You usually cannot feel it. A bone density scan, called DXA, is the standard test. Ask your doctor whether you are due for one based on your age and risk factors.

Visit the clinic

Netra Integrative Health Clinic provides Ayurvedic and Chinese medicine consultations and acupuncture as complementary care alongside your own physician. We are at 5001 Hadley Road, Suite 210, South Plainfield, NJ 07080, open Monday to Saturday, 9:00 AM to 6:00 PM, by appointment only. Call (908) 402-7301 or request an appointment online.

This article is general information and is not medical advice. It does not replace an assessment by your own doctor, who can review your bone health, test results and medicines.